Digital Marketing Strategy Review

A critical friend for your digital marketing strategy.

Independent senior challenge for organisations that need an honest view of whether their customers, proposition, channels, content, journeys, measurement and investment are pulling in the same direction.

Discuss a strategy review →
The honest outside view

Good teams can still get too close to the plan.

Strategies accumulate assumptions. Priorities get inherited, channels develop their own targets and activity gathers momentum long after the original reasoning has faded. Internally, it can become difficult to challenge the plan without also appearing to challenge the people behind it.

I act as a critical friend: close enough to understand the commercial context, but independent enough to say where the strategy is strong, where the evidence is thin and where activity has overtaken clarity. The review is not designed to manufacture a transformation programme or steer you towards a particular platform or agency.

The review lenses

Focus, alignment and evidence.

01 / Focus

Customers and choices

Priority segments, audiences, ICPs, needs and commercial opportunity, including what the strategy deliberately chooses not to pursue.

02 / Alignment

Proposition and activation

Whether proposition, content, search, paid, CRM, social, customer journeys and technology support the same strategic intent.

03 / Evidence

Measurement and investment

The outcomes, KPIs, assumptions, capability and budget choices behind the plan, separating confidence from what the evidence can genuinely support.

When it earns its keep

Before another year of activity hardens into the plan.

Particularly useful when the organisation needs confidence in the direction before committing more budget, changing agency, adding technology or asking teams to deliver against another crowded roadmap.

  • An annual or multi-year marketing strategy is being set
  • Performance has stalled and every channel has a different explanation
  • The plan contains plenty of activity but few explicit choices
  • Customer segments, ICPs and journeys have drifted apart
  • AI, search or technology pressure is distorting the priorities
  • Leaders want independent assurance before approving investment
James Gray, independent digital strategy consultant
Senior judgement, no sales agenda

Twenty years of seeing where the weak joints tend to hide.

I have worked across consultancy, agency and in-house leadership, connecting commercial objectives with customer experience, marketing, data and technology. That breadth matters here because apparently isolated channel problems are often symptoms of a wider strategic disconnect.

Where the main question is current performance rather than the strategy itself, the broader Digital Performance Review may be the better fit. Where the direction is broadly understood but a live decision needs resolving, a Digital Direction Day can turn it into an agreed order of action.

What you receive

Useful challenge, captured clearly.

Strategy red-team

Direct feedback on the assumptions, choices and gaps in the current plan.

Joined-up assessment

A view across audience, proposition, journeys, channels, content and capability.

Evidence and measurement gaps

The claims that need baselining before they should influence investment.

Prioritised recommendations

A practical Now, Next and Later order, with trade-offs made explicit.

Invite the challenge

Let’s find out whether the strategy really holds together.

Share the current plan, the questions around it and the decision waiting on the other side. I’ll tell you honestly where an independent review can add value.

Start a conversation →